Is Kickboxing Wing Chun OK?

-
This is a post regarding kickboxing Wing Chun. Is it right or wrong?

---

This discussion is related to the comments on this post 

"I love the concept of Wing Chun. Any videos of it working (and not looking like sloppy kickboxing) in the streets or cage?"

"I remember watching a podcast with a wing chun guy who decided to start doing a lot of sparring. I remember him saying it took a while to adapt it and part of the problem was when he started sparring a lot, his attempt to modernize it really just turned into him learning kickboxing instead. Can't remember his name but I remember his sparring didn't look too good, though it was a lot better than most of the traditional martial arts v kickboxing videos you see."

---
This is the discussion between Brone and Smart Research.

Brone:
"Unless they sign up for kickboxing classes it's still Wing Chun, just adjusted for realistic resistance > a perfect movie demo where no1 is resisting you"

Smart Research:
"Brione PT Let's change kickboxing to another style, like Sumo.  

Suppose the most practical style were Sumo, and all Chunners were using Sumo. Would you still say, 'They are using Wing Chun'?  

Now, imagine all Sumo wrestlers were using Kickboxing but still claimed it was Sumo. Would that make sense?  

When you use Kickboxing, your Wing Chun is gone. You're using Kickboxing structure and techniques. So, where's the Wing Chun?  

Would you say the same if you were using Muay Thai and still claimed it was Wing Chun?  

You guys don't even know what you're talking about."

---

Solve your Wing Chun issues with these now:


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

AI Chat GPT Debunks Mainstream Wing Chun

-
Join this list if you wish to participate in our webinar or seminar training to resolve your Wing Chun issues. Click here. This post further proves that mainstream Wing Chun is Unscientific. Disclosure   Mainstream Wing Chun  Mainstream Wing Chun Mainstream Wing Chun ---- Chat GPT 's analysis: "Great question. Let’s break this down from a purely scientific and biomechanical perspective—forgetting Wing Chun exists, and imagining a new martial art that teaches practitioners to jam their arms into the center of their body to perform blocks, diversions, and strikes. 1. Anatomical Considerations The arms have natural range of motion that allow them to move freely to the sides, diagonally, and forward. Jamming the arms into the centerline of the body restricts this range. The shoulders, elbows, and wrists are designed to work in coordinated arcs. Tucking or jamming them too tightly to the center introduces tension in the joints and limits fluidity. Shoulder impingeme...
Read more

Why Ancient Martial Arts Can’t Be Trained Like Modern Combat Sports – A Proven Analysis from an Expert

-
In martial arts, misconceptions about training methods are everywhere, even among seasoned practitioners. As an experienced martial artist and instructor, I want to clarify some of the most critical errors people make when training traditional techniques. This post isn’t just about tips; it’s a demonstration of the depth of my expertise—an understanding that most martial artists don’t have. To dive deeper into authentic training methods, check out my online Wing Chun course at [www.skilloneness.com](http://www.skilloneness.com). 1. Misconceptions Around Training Ancient Techniques on Punching Bags Many traditional martial artists don’t realize that practicing ancient strikes on a punching bag is fundamentally flawed. These techniques are designed to be executed against targets that are firmly grounded on the floor, simulating the reality of human contact and direct force application. When the target is free to move or sway backward, like a punching bag, it disrupts the strike’s purpose...
Read more

Losers of Mainstream Wing Chun

-
This blog post exposes the bad characters of mainstream Wing Chun practitioners. These guys (losers) post nasty stuff on Facebook to smear and ridicule people because they can't defend their unscientific mainstream Wing Chun after it is being exposed. I will be exposing their characters and doings here for the public to judge them.  There are a few guys who post stuff that is related to personal attacks. Instead of defending their Wing Chun with logical arguments, they choose to do personal attacks with videos, photos and so on (including online stalking). I'll post their Facebook content and update this blog post. Chris Riley, instructor of Ving Tsun Salisbury.  Facebook posts by Chris Riley: "Let me show you guys what a loser looks like” then posts the video of him kissing a dude 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣Smart Research 🌈🌈🌈🌈💅💅💅💅💅" "Smart Research blah blah … same nonsense …. Keep trying mr lady fingers 🤣🤣🤣" "Smart Research you back to childish stupi...
Read more